A close-up of a cake being decorated with white frosting using a piping bag at a Maui bakery. The cake has a smooth, textured yellow surface, and the piping bag is adding a delicate, wavy border to the edge. The background is blurred.
A simple pink heart with a red outline, reminiscent of the charming decor in a Maui bakery. The heart is centered on a white background and has a smooth, symmetrical shape, symbolizing love and affection.

Best Maui Bakery

Cakes

Ordering custom cakes on Maui is a delightful way to celebrate special occasions, such as birthdays, anniversaries, retirements, baby showers, and more!

Pre-Order

"I went to order last minute for the cake and she really accomodate me it was really delicious and pretty. I usually go whole foods but this was really good. Specialy my family dont really like to sweet cakes but this is one just right very ono!!!"

Google

Create Your Dream Cake!

Maui Custom Cakes

The Art of Custom Cakes

Our talented pastry chefs have honed their craft to perfection, creating stunning masterpieces that will impress. From playful designs to elegant creations, these skilled artisans can bring any cake idea to life.

Making Your Cake Personal

One of the greatest benefits of ordering a custom cake is the ability to personalize it. Whether you have a specific theme in mind, a favorite color palette, or a unique design concept, professional bakers can turn your vision into reality. Imagine surprising your loved one with a cake that reflects their passions and interests, making the occasion truly special.

Cake Flavors to Savor

While the visual appeal of a custom cake is essential, taste is equally important. Paukūkalo Sweets and Treats offers various delectable flavors to satisfy every palate. From classic vanilla and chocolate to exotic flavors like passion fruit or lilikoi, there is a flavor combination to suit every celebration. Indulging in a custom cake means savoring each bite, as the flavors are carefully crafted to perfection.

Convenience and Delivery

Ordering a custom cake on Maui is easy and convenient. We offer online ordering (72-hours notice), local pickup or professional delivery services to ensure that your custom cake arrives safely at your desired location, taking the stress out of transportation.

A number 60 cake, crafted by a renowned Maui bakery, features buttercream swirls in navy blue and white. It's adorned with white flowers, metallic silver accents, and white chocolate geometric shapes. The cake is elegant and festive, presented on a silver metallic surface.
A blue round cake designed as a beach scene, with edible sand, sea shells, ocean waves, and flip-flops on top. A sign reads "Happy ½ Birthday Emma" in pink and green letters. Created by a Maui bakery, it features buttercream accents and fondant elements that capture the island spirit.
A rectangular cake from a renowned Maui bakery, adorned with red anthuriums, strawberries, blueberries, purple and yellow flowers, and photos at the corners, showcases "YANAGIDA STRENGTH & FITNESS" in the center. Above the name are the words "Motivation, Education, Dedication".
A square birthday cake crafted by a Maui bakery, featuring a drum design with images of a band, decorated with strawberries, whipped cream, and a large number 75 on top. The message "Happy Birthday Mick" is written on the front.
A round cake from a Maui bakery is decorated with yellow frosting petals resembling a sunflower, with a brown center mimicking sunflower seeds. The cake sits on a reflective surface with the edge of a written message, "Happy Birthday Norma," partially visible.
A round, frosted birthday cake with "Happy Birthday" written on top in elegant script. Baked by a renowned Maui bakery, the cake is decorated with swirls of white frosting, colorful sprinkles, and sliced strawberries around the sides and as a garnish on top.

Pre-Order Your Custom Cake Today!

Please allow 72 hours in advanced notice for cake orders. Pick-up or delivery available. Create your dream cake using the order form below (prices will be shown as you build).

Customer Name
Order Type
For orders over $150.00, the delivery fee is waived. However, for deliveries to the Lahaina area, a charge of $50 will be added instead of the standard delivery fee. Delivery areas and prices are listed and selected at the end of this form.

Who or what are you celebrating?

Occasion?
Would you like names or a message written on your cake?

Build your Dream Cake!

Please note that the base prices apply to single-tier, basic cakes like Vanilla and Chocolate. Basic fillings such as Whip Cream or Vanilla Buttercream are also included in the base price. Any other cake flavor, filling or decoration marked with an "*" will have an additional charge on top of the base price.

 

Vegan, Gluten Free upon request, see price add-ons below

 

In order to fulfill your wishes, specialty decorations such as fondant, fresh flowers, or custom-themed decorations may incur additional charges beyond those listed. If so, we will contact you to discuss your options.

Cake Style
Our cakes are single-tier and consist of 3 layers, and are filled with 2 layers of your chosen filling. Please inquire about pricing for stacked cakes (more than one tier).

Decorate & Customize Your Cake

We are thrilled to customize your cake just the way you want it! Please keep in mind that adding special decorations may come with an additional charge, depending on your choice, and it is all at the discretion of the cake decorator.
Do you have a specific cake vision or photos to share?
Here is a summary of your cake order.
Price: $0.00
=
Please do the math to make sure you're not a robot. (* asterisk represents x multiplication sign).

We are sad to announce that we closed our Paukūkalo location.  Contact Us if you have any qustions.